This site may earn affiliate commissions from the links on this folio. Terms of use.

FFXV

Square Enix'south port of Concluding Fantasy Fifteen has received potent reviews and overall acclaim from multiple publications. Eurogamer declared the PC version "unlocks the game's full visual potential," and other sites take given the game similar accolades. They've also taken detect of how much hardware firepower you need to actually push button the game at its highest visual settings. A new investigation suggests some of those requirements may be artificially college than they should be, thanks to the game'southward DRM implementation.

DSO Gaming put both versions of the game through equivalent tests and the results aren't fifty-fifty particularly shut. Not only does the pirated version launch much more apace, saved games too load faster at 58 seconds for the pirated version versus 100 seconds for the legal copy. A video of the load time differences is embedded below:

While 720p tests favored the Steam version of the game, at 1080p the situation inverse. In all cases, the pirated version of the game was faster, by 5 pct to a whopping 33 per centum, depending on the scene. DSO Gaming also reported the frame rate on the pirated version has a tendency to drib later x-15 minutes, while the frame rate doesn't drop on the pirated version. The site logged a 60fps frame rate after x minutes on the Steam version and a 75fps frame rate on the pirated copy after the same corporeality of fourth dimension. None of these problems have been fixed in the latest game patch. Finally, they institute the Steam version stutters more than, thank you to abiding hard bulldoze accesses that hit the game'due south overall smoothness and presentation.

The implications of these findings are straightforward: The piracy protections baked into the game are hit overall functioning, causing a significant prepare of problems. Companies regularly deny it happens, but tests like this punch holes in such claims. The impact of Denuvo (which FFXV uses) and other DRM schemes appears to vary depending on the game. Other potential factors include which version of Denuvo is used, how it's implemented, and the presence of other DRM methods. In Doom, removing Denuvo had a 4-6 percentage impact on performance at 1080p. The FFXV affect, in contrast, is significantly larger.

You'll need to click on the paradigm and zoom in, but you can see how the Denuvo version of the game is at sixty FPS while the pirated version hits 73 FPS. Images by DSO Gaming.

Be advised, yet, this trend tin run both ways. ExtremeTech does not endorse or disregard piracy, just as a matter of technical commentary, the version of a game you can find at sites like the Pirate Bay is often the launch-solar day season. In cases where after updates are bachelor, they nevertheless may not correspond with the final title. This increases the likelihood that bugs or other problems will themselves lead to a negative overall experience.

At the aforementioned time, however, issues like this brand it genuinely tough to recommend a centre road on DRM. Most gamers are willing to tolerate DRM if it's acceptably permissive, and storefronts like Steam strike a balance between allowing gamers to share titles or install them to multiple machines and the need to protect the publisher's IP. Simply information technology's one thing to put a limit on business relationship sharing or simultaneous installations. It's another to enquire players to take significantly lower performance. Last Fantasy XV may be best experienced on PC, only Denuvo is doing the game no favors.

Our own rule of thumb for whether a game'due south DRM implementation hits performance likewise hard would exist this:  If DRM touch on rises in a higher place v-vi percent in any metric — frame times, frame rates, UI responsiveness, etc — and so the impact is too high and the implementation needs to be fine-tuned or changed. A five-6 percent functioning loss is generally beneath the threshold humans tin reliably detect; the divergence between a steady 60fps and a steady 57fps isn't very noticeable. In one case you get-go hitting 10 percent, you lot're in the range people will regularly detect.